Dan wrote to ask whether Julie’s message meant she still wanted to date him if he waited. She told him she missed him and loved him. She also said she needed to walk away so she could make her own decisions.

On this page
  1. Dan’s letter
  2. Julie’s message
  3. How I would respond

Dan’s letter

Hey Joshua,

I wonder if you can help me understand what this girl is really trying to say to me. I think she likes me, but will we have to wait a while? Am I wrong in assuming that? Any insights or advice you can offer me would be appreciated.

Thanks,

Dan

Julie’s message

Dear Dan,

After Saturday afternoon, I was ready to stop communicating with you. But then I was able to think about it more rationally, and I realized that you deserve an explanation about what’s going to happen.

It’s Monday morning now, and I miss you. But I don’t want my loneliness and my horniness to affect our outcome. I need you to understand that I love you, but this isn’t what I want or need right now.

You were correct when you said that I’m scared of falling in love again. But my real fear is letting somebody get so close to me that they influence my decisions. I’ve always gone along with the guy I was with. I can’t do that to myself anymore, no matter how perfect and amazing the guy is for me.

Pure and simple, I can’t let anyone get in my way of being me and doing what I want to do. I can’t let other people control me anymore. I know you wouldn’t do that intentionally to me, but the fact that I felt guilty about leaving you k, and about the possible effects on you from me doing what I want to do is more than enough to tell me that I have to walk away from you. And I have to walk away now, before I start thinking about it too much and flipping out that I made a bad decision.

You haven’t done anything wrong, Dan. You’ve been amazing to me. I hate the fact that this has to happen. I’m sorry this note is so long, but I always freeze up when I get emotional. I wanted to get my thoughts down in writing so we can discuss them later.

I love you (too much),

Julie

Woman in a lavender shirt holding a mug beside a window.
Give the requested space and choose a way to handle any practical details that still need attention.

How I would respond

Dan, she tells you what she needs right now. You can acknowledge that without trying to persuade her or making a promise to wait. A short reply is enough: “Thank you for telling me. I care about you and I’ll respect your decision. I wish you well.”

If she reaches out later, you can decide then whether a conversation feels right for you both. In the meantime, give yourself permission to move on. Talk it through with someone you trust or make plans that help you focus on the days ahead.